Since we're approaching feature freeze on V2.0, I guess it's time to lay down some guidelines here.

Henceforth on app, library, or script posts

##Comments

should be used for

• general feedback
• feature requests
• "bite sized" bug reports (it's down, doesn't work on XP, etc.; anything that doesn't need much context or is trivial to reproduce)

##Answers

should be used for

• detailed bug reports
  • comments on bug reports can serve any discussion needed to reproduce them

##Edits on the Question

should be used for

• samples
• project updates

Any more detailed discussion should be taken off of Stack Apps, perhaps to an app specific chat room, mailing list, project issue tracker, or what have you.

Since we're approaching feature freeze on V2.0, I guess it's time to lay down some guidelines here.

Henceforth on app, library, or script posts

Comments

should be used for

• general feedback
• feature requests
• "bite sized" bug reports (it's down, doesn't work on XP, etc.; anything that doesn't need much context or is trivial to reproduce)

Answers

should be used for

• detailed bug reports
  • comments on bug reports can serve any discussion needed to reproduce them

Edits on the Question

should be used for

• samples
• project updates

Any more detailed discussion should be taken off of Stack Apps, perhaps to an app specific chat room, mailing list, project issue tracker, or what have you.